I am very intrigued by the sociological theories of religion. As a man of faith, my interest always perks up whenever faith and religion comes up in academic discussion. Early on I would often approach such discussion with hostility. However, as I have matured I always approach discussions with an open mind and willingness to learn. I agree with Durkheim's views of religion. It definitely serves to unify people and creates a collective consciousness. However, I would say that it goes too far, often seeking conformity to accepted behavior rather than acceptance of beliefs. For example, if I go to a conservative Christian church, although I may hold fervently to all accepted doctrine, if I am covered in tattoos or got a new tattoo while attending, i would be somewhat ostracized. I do think that religion provides for some moral cohesion. Recently I had my students read a proposed bill that would define life to begin at conception, virtually outlawing abortion. I was intrigued at how many wrote fervently in support of the bill on a moral/religious basis. However, when I asked these students if they were religious, most said not really. I believe that is a result of the collective religious moral conscious Durkheim spoke of. I think that the picture below represents the general feeling that God has blessed America and we must honor him if we are to persevere.
Weber and Marx bring up points that particularly interest me. As I have sat through service after service, I have heard messages on greed, charity, hard work, etc. However, when you look at the development of our "JudeoChristian" America, it does not seem to match what is taught in the Bible and other religious texts. I think that the huge amount of spending on elaborate churches, rather than helping others will eventually cause people to depart from those churches. My belief is echoed by Dan Harris in this clip:
http://abcnews.go.com/GMA/video/2011-predictions-faith-america-religion-faith-america-dan-harris-12522736
I personally have always thought that a truly Christian community would be far more communistic and socialistic than we see in the United States. However, many including Martin Luther King Jr. in the following article, would disagree.
http://www.redmoonrising.com/AmericanBabylon/christandcomm.htm Although Weber discusses the Protestant ethic, he fails to mention that many if not most protestants do not believe in John Calvin's predestination. Jesus even said that it is more difficult for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle than for a rich man to enter heaven. This leads me to believe that religion and faith had less to do with the economic development in America than Weber postulates. Ultimately I think that faith is powerful in shaping individuals and groups, however it is almost always checked by other aspects in society. An article that critiques Weber's view and provides an alternative view of the economic development of Protestant areas is,
Was Weber Wrong? A Human Capital Theory of Protestant Economic History. by Sascha Becker and Ludger Wohmann.
http://www.eric.ed.gov/ERICWebPortal/contentdelivery/servlet/ERICServlet?accno=ED498129
The lyrics of the song below by the Casting Crowns echoes my frustration with how most churches and Christians are today:
It's crowded in worship today
As she slips in
Trying to fade into the faces
The girls' teasing laughter is carrying farther than they know
Farther than they know
CHORUS
But if we are the Body
Why aren't His arms reaching
Why aren't His hands healing
Why aren't His words teaching
And if we are the Body
Why aren't His feet going
Why is His love not showing them there is a way
There is a way
A traveler is far away from home
He sheds his coat
And quietly sinks into the back row
The weight of their judgmental glances tells him that his chances
Are better out on the road
CHORUS
But if we are the Body
Why aren't His arms reaching
Why aren't His hands healing
Why aren't His words teaching
And if we are the Body
Why aren't His feet going
Why is His love not showing them there is a way
Jesus paid much too high a price
For us to pick and choose who should come
And we are the Body of Christ
Chorus (2x)
If we are the body
Why aren't His arms reaching
Why aren't His hands healing
Why aren't His words teaching
And if we are the body
Why aren't His feet going
Why is His love not showing them there is a way
Jesus is the way
Whatever your personal beliefs are, everyone should try to study the true development of America and decide if this is truly a Christian nation or not. The following sites provide opposing views:
3. Symbolic activities that express a group's spiritual convictions.
4. Everything that pertains to the veryday world and things specifically not religious.
6. An object or living thing that a religious group regards with special reverence.
8. Formal organizations that tend to see themselves, and are seen by society, as the primary and legitimate religious institutions.
9. The belief in one god.
1. the intensity and consistency of preactice of a person's or group's faith.
2. The belief in many gods.
3. An institutionalized system of symbols, beliefs, values, and practices by which a group of people interprets and responds to what they feel is sacred and that provides answers to questions of ultimate meaning.
5. That which is set apart from ordinary activity for worship, seen as holy, and protected by special rites and rituals.
7. Groups that have broken off from an established church.